New batchesJob or full-time? One course for bothNew: Prelims PYQ Book ₹199Free: 500 Prelims PYQs with explanationsJob + APSC? Evening classes, 7 to 9 PMEvery class recorded, rewatch anytimePrelims + Mains + Interview, one batchPrelims only? Crash Course from ₹2,499Join now

APSC Answer Writing (Daily) based on Assam Tribune – 09/11/2026

By Amit BiswakarmaPublished 3 min read
This question comes from today’s Assam Tribune notes:Full Assam Tribune notes →Only today’s MCQs →

For APSC CCE and other Assam Competitive examinations aspirants, practicing Daily Answer Writing is vital. This blog covers the most important Main question and its model Answer from the Assam Tribune today (09-11-2026).

APSC CCE Foundation ProgrammeFor working professionals and full-time aspirantsAPSC CCE Foundation Programme₹24,999 ₹44,999 44% offView course

Mains Answer Writing

From The Assam Tribune, 9 November 2026

Mains question · 15 marks · 250 words

Q. Recently, Assam de-reserved Village Grazing Reserve land in Dhekiajuli to settle landless families. In this context, discuss the legal safeguards for village grazing land in Assam and their conflict with the need to give land to the landless. Suggest measures to reconcile the two. (250 words, 15 marks)

Model answer

Introduction: On 4 November 2026, the Assam Cabinet de-reserved 987 bighas of Village Grazing Reserve (VGR) land in Dhekiajuli, Sonitpur. The land is for 2,016 landless labourers and members of Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe communities. The Cabinet promised an equal area of new VGR elsewhere. A VGR is village common land kept for free grazing, so the decision sets land for the landless against protection of the commons.

1. Legal safeguards for village grazing land in Assam

SafeguardWhat it provides
Assam Land and Revenue Regulation (ALRR), 1886: Rules 83 to 91A grazing ground is created only after inquiry, demarcation, public notice, hearing of objections and a final notice. It is then entered in the grazing-ground register.
Rules 92 and 95Villagers may graze cattle there free of charge. Nobody may occupy the land for any purpose other than grazing.
Rule 95-AGrazing land can be de-reserved only by a final order of the State Government under this rule. Until then, it stays protected common land.
Gauhati High Court rulingsIn the Kundargaon case (2005), the High Court held that a Deputy Commissioner cannot settle VGR land without a Rule 95-A order. The court has repeatedly stressed that grazing reserves must be protected.
Jagpal Singh v. State of Punjab (2011)The Supreme Court directed every State to frame schemes to evict illegal occupants of village common land. The land was to be restored for the common use of villagers.
Equal-land rule (Mission Basundhara 2.0)A notification of 11 November 2022 said an equal area of government land, subject to availability, must be reserved when grazing land is de-reserved. It was a one-time measure that lapsed after 31 December 2023.

2. Conflict with the need to give land to the landless

  • Constitutional duty to redistribute: Article 38 asks the State to secure a social order based on social, economic and political justice. Article 39(b) asks that the community’s material resources be distributed to best serve the common good.
  • Commons also serve the poor: Rule 92 lets villagers graze cattle on the reserve free of charge. This matters most to poor households that cannot afford private pasture, so taking it away can shift hardship from one poor group to another.
  • Equal area is not equal use: A replacement plot far from the village or without water is of little use to its herders. The 2022 rule allowed fallback land anywhere in the same circle or district.
  • Weak title for beneficiaries: Courts insist on a valid Rule 95-A order. So families settled through a faulty process may later face cancellation or eviction.
  • Risk of rewarding encroachment: Jagpal Singh held that long occupation or political links cannot justify regularisation. It allowed only narrow exceptions, such as government leases to landless labourers or Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes.

3. Way Forward: measures to reconcile the two

  • Follow the law fully: The Revenue and Disaster Management Department should publish the Rule 95-A order and proceedings for every de-reservation.
  • Replace land nearby: Deputy Commissioners should first look for replacement land in the same revenue village. An independent check should confirm its access, water and capacity for the village’s livestock.
  • Consult the village: District officials should hear the affected community before the new reserve is notified.
  • Use other land first: Government khas land (unsettled government land) and ceiling surplus land were also covered by Mission Basundhara 2.0. These should be offered to landless families before village commons.
  • Clear eligibility and secure title: Beneficiary criteria and lists should be public. Each family should get a recorded, legally secure land right.

Conclusion: The Dhekiajuli decision serves a just aim. It will be fair only if Rule 95-A is followed and the new reserve is as usable as the old one. Assam can settle its landless without shrinking its commons, provided every de-reservation is lawful, open and backed by real replacement land.

Prepare with SuchitraACS

See all APSC CCE courses
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted