APSC Answer Writing (Daily) based on Assam Tribune – 08/11/2026
For APSC CCE and other Assam Competitive examinations aspirants, practicing Daily Answer Writing is vital. This blog covers the most important Main question and its model Answer from the Assam Tribune today (08-11-2026).
For working professionals and full-time aspirantsAPSC CCE Foundation Programme₹24,999 Mains Answer Writing
From The Assam Tribune, 8 November 2026
Q. Migratory birds such as the Amur falcon often rest on wetlands that have no legal protection. Critically examine the gaps in India’s Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) process in safeguarding such habitats. Suggest measures to reconcile industrial development with habitat protection in Assam. (250 words, 15 marks)
Model answer
Introduction: Nearly all the world’s Amur falcons are thought to stop over in North-East India each autumn. Yet many draft Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) reports for industries near the unprotected Dharamtul wetlands of Morigaon do not mention the falcon at all.
1. India’s EIA process: the safeguards it offers on paper
- Prior clearance by law: The EIA Notification, 2006 makes prior environmental clearance compulsory for listed projects. The Centre clears Category A projects and the state authority clears Category B.
- Clear stages: A project goes through screening (for Category B only), scoping, public consultation and appraisal.
- Public hearing: The District Magistrate, or an officer not below Additional District Magistrate, presides over the hearing with the State Pollution Control Board. At least 30 days’ newspaper notice is required.
- Expert appraisal: Central and state Expert Appraisal Committees study the report and recommend clearance with conditions or rejection.
2. Gaps in the EIA process in safeguarding such habitats
- Species left out: Many draft EIAs near Dharamtul do not count the falcons at all. Some also ignore elephants from the Amsoi and Kholahat Reserve Forests and the Gangetic river dolphins of the Kopili.
- Unprotected wetlands fall outside the net: The Wetlands (Conservation and Management) Rules, 2017 apply only to Ramsar sites and notified wetlands. Dharamtul is neither, so no rule makes an EIA treat it as sensitive.
- Short baseline studies: Terms of Reference for EIAs usually ask for field data from just one season, other than the monsoon. The falcons stay at Dharamtul only about 15 to 20 days, mostly in November, so a survey at another time can miss them.
- Conflict of interest: The project proponent hires and pays the EIA consultant. Accreditation by the Quality Council of India’s National Accreditation Board for Education and Training (QCI-NABET) has not fully removed this worry.
- Token hearings: Villagers near Dharamtul allege that they were kept out and not allowed to speak. The Draft EIA Notification, 2020 had even proposed cutting the notice from 30 to 20 days.
- Piecemeal and after-the-fact approvals: Projects are appraised one at a time, though Morigaon already has a cement plant near Jagiroad. On 18 November 2025, the Supreme Court, by a 2:1 majority, recalled its May 2025 Vanashakti judgment that had barred post-facto (after-the-event) clearances.
3. Way Forward: measures to reconcile industrial development with habitat protection in Assam
- Independent ecological study: The appraising authority, such as the State Environment Impact Assessment Authority (SEIAA), Assam, should demand an independent study covering November. It must assess the falcons, elephants and dolphins before any decision.
- Notify the wetland: The Assam State Wetlands Authority, notified in November 2018, should notify Dharamtul under the 2017 Rules. New or expanded industries and land conversion would then be barred inside it.
- Community reserve: Under Section 36C of the Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972, the state can declare community land a community reserve. This happens when villagers volunteer to protect wildlife. Any change in land use there then needs the management committee’s resolution and State Government approval.
- Buffer and bird-safe rules: No unit should draw groundwater or release effluent that harms the wetland. A buffer should keep heavy work away during falcon season, and power lines should be made safer against collision and electrocution.
- Learn from Pangti: Mass falcon killing in Nagaland came to light in 2012. Village councils, eco-clubs, the state government and Wildlife Trust of India made Pangti a safe haven by 2013. A similar village-led model can work in Morigaon.
- Flyway commitments: The Amur falcon is listed in Appendix II of the Convention on Migratory Species (CMS). India’s next Central Asian Flyway action plan for migratory birds, after the 2018-2023 plan, should list plains stopovers like Dharamtul.
Conclusion: On balance, India’s EIA process is sound on paper but weak in the field, because it counts only what lies inside protected boundaries. Assam does not have to choose between factories and falcons: notified wetlands, honest field studies and a real voice for villagers can keep both.
Prepare with SuchitraACS
APSC CCE Foundation Programme₹24,999
APSC Mains Mentorship Programme (MMP)₹9,999
APSC Prelims Crash Course 2027 (GS + CSAT)₹5,999 


