To excel in the APSC Mains exam, it is crucial to develop a strong command over answer writing. Today’s question focuses on the deeply rooted issue of superstitious beliefs, which continues to plague several parts of India. Addressing this topic not only prepares you for questions related to social issues but also sharpens your ability to critically analyze societal challenges.
APSC Answer Writing (Daily) – 27/09/2024
Question:
The recent incident in Nagaon, where a hospital allegedly withheld the body of a deceased patient due to unpaid medical bills, has sparked outrage and raised concerns about the ethical and legal obligations of healthcare institutions. In light of this incident, critically examine the following:
- The ethical considerations surrounding the practice of withholding bodies of deceased patients due to unpaid bills.
- The legal provisions in India that address such situations and protect the rights of patients and their families.
- The role of the government and regulatory bodies in ensuring that healthcare institutions adhere to ethical and legal standards in handling deceased patients.
- Suggest measures to prevent such incidents in the future and ensure that healthcare remains accessible and compassionate, even in cases of financial hardship.
Model Answer:
The incident in Nagaon, where a hospital allegedly refused to release the body of a deceased patient due to unpaid medical bills, underscores a deeply concerning ethical and legal dilemma in the healthcare sector. While hospitals have a right to recover dues, withholding a deceased patient’s body is a violation of human dignity and the rights of the bereaved family.
Ethical Considerations:
Ethically, healthcare institutions have a moral obligation to treat patients with compassion and respect, even in cases of financial hardship. Withholding a body due to unpaid bills is a blatant disregard for human dignity and causes immense emotional distress to the grieving family. It is also a violation of the right to a dignified burial or cremation, which is enshrined in various international human rights instruments.
Legal Provisions in India:
In India, there are several legal provisions that address such situations. The Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct, Etiquette, and Ethics) Regulations, 2002, prohibits doctors from refusing to provide medical care or withholding treatment due to non-payment of fees. The Consumer Protection Act, 1986, also provides recourse to patients and their families in cases of medical negligence or unfair trade practices. Additionally, various state-level legislations and court judgments have upheld the right to a dignified burial or cremation and condemned the practice of withholding bodies due to unpaid bills.
Role of Government and Regulatory Bodies:
The government and regulatory bodies have a crucial role in ensuring that healthcare institutions adhere to ethical and legal standards. This includes:
- Enforcing existing regulations and guidelines that prohibit the withholding of bodies due to unpaid bills.
- Strengthening the grievance redressal mechanisms for patients and their families.
- Conducting regular audits and inspections of healthcare institutions to ensure compliance with ethical and legal standards.
- Promoting awareness among healthcare providers and the public about the rights of patients and their families.
Preventive Measures:
To prevent such incidents in the future, the following measures can be considered:
- Hospitals should have clear and transparent policies regarding billing and payment, and these should be communicated to patients and their families at the time of admission.
- Hospitals should explore alternative mechanisms for recovering dues, such as installment plans or mediation, rather than resorting to unethical practices like withholding bodies.
- The government should consider establishing a dedicated fund to assist families in cases of financial hardship, ensuring that they can access healthcare and receive the bodies of their loved ones without undue burden.
- Strengthening the public healthcare system and expanding health insurance coverage can also help to reduce the financial burden on patients and their families.
Conclusion:
The incident in Nagaon serves as a stark reminder of the need to uphold ethical and legal standards in healthcare. While financial considerations are important, they should never overshadow the principles of compassion, dignity, and respect for human life. By adopting a multi-pronged approach that includes ethical awareness, legal enforcement, and financial support mechanisms, we can ensure that healthcare remains accessible and compassionate for all, regardless of their financial circumstances.
✨ Looking for top-quality APSC online coaching at an affordable price?
🔔 Join Our WhatsApp Study Group!
For exclusive access to premium quality content, including study materials, current affairs, MCQs, and model answers for APSC CCE and other Assam competitive exams.
Click here to join: SuchitraACS Study WhatsApp Group
📚 Want to know more about SuchitraACS’s most affordable courses?
Click here to know more: SuchitraACS Courses for APSC CCE and Assam Competitive Examinations
