APSC Answer Writing (Daily) based on Assam Tribune – 14/11/2026
For APSC CCE and other Assam Competitive examinations aspirants, practicing Daily Answer Writing is vital. This blog covers the most important Main question and its model Answer from the Assam Tribune today (14-11-2026).
For working professionals and full-time aspirantsAPSC CCE Foundation Programme₹24,999 Mains Answer Writing
From The Assam Tribune, 14 November 2026
Q. Extrajudicial killings by the police weaken the rule of law and the criminal justice process. Discuss in the context of Assam and suggest measures for police reform. (250 words, 15 marks)
Model answer
Introduction: An extrajudicial killing is a killing by the police without the sanction of a court. In its own affidavits, Assam admitted 171 police encounters between May 2021 and August 2022, in which 56 persons were killed and 145 were injured.
1. How extrajudicial killings weaken the rule of law and the criminal justice process
| Aspect | How an encounter killing harms it |
|---|---|
| Right to life (Article 21) | Article 21 says no person shall be deprived of life except according to procedure established by law. An encounter replaces that procedure with one officer’s decision. |
| Presumption of innocence | The person killed is only an accused, not a convict. Only a court can decide guilt, after a fair trial. |
| Separation of roles | The police investigate, while the courts judge and punish. An encounter makes the police investigator, judge and executioner at once. |
| Truth and evidence | A dead accused cannot be tried, so the case often stays unsolved. Accomplices and motives may never come out in court. |
| Equality before law | In May 2025 the Supreme Court restated its 2014 position that no one, including the police, is above the law. |
| Culture of impunity | The Court warned that praising encounters as “effective policing” creates a climate of impunity. |
2. The context of Assam
- High murder rate: Official data show that Assam averaged more than two murders a day over the last five years. The State reported 858 murder cases in 2025 alone.
- Guwahati’s share: Guwahati had the highest five-year total, at 277 cases. Its yearly count fell only slightly, from 74 (2022) to 62 (2025).
- Weak case closure: Many murder cases never reach a logical end, and this failure fuels more crime. In cases that anger the public, the police are suspected of using encounters instead.
- Encounter record: The 56 deaths in 2021-22 included 4 custodial deaths. The State says it filed charge sheets in 125 of the 171 cases and followed the 2014 guidelines.
- Court scrutiny: The Gauhati High Court dismissed a public interest petition on these encounters in 2023. On 28 May 2025 the Supreme Court set this aside and asked the Assam Human Rights Commission to inquire independently. It did not rule on any officer’s guilt.
- Recent questions: People ask how a restrained accused in the Boragaon hotel shooting case got hold of a police weapon before his encounter. A court had earlier ordered adequate security for him in custody and barred physical abuse.
3. Way Forward: Measures for Police Reform
- Follow the 2014 guidelines: The Director General of Police, Assam, should enforce the 16 guidelines of People’s Union for Civil Liberties v State of Maharashtra (2014). This applies in every case. These include a First Information Report, a probe by the Criminal Investigation Department or another police station, and ballistic tests of weapons.
- No quick rewards: The Home Department should give no out-of-turn promotion or instant gallantry award soon after an encounter, as the guidelines direct.
- Timely inquiries: Magistrates should promptly finish the inquiry required in every police-firing death. It moved from Section 176 of the Code of Criminal Procedure to Section 196 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023.
- Stronger oversight body: The State should give the State Police Accountability Commission, set up under the Assam Police Act, 2007, its own investigators. A 2020 review by the Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative found that the law does not provide for them.
- Prakash Singh directives: Assam should fully implement Prakash Singh v Union of India (2006). This means separate investigation and law-and-order wings and a minimum two-year tenure for key officers.
- Capacity and community: The Guwahati police need more staff, better technology, training and intelligence-gathering. Citizens’ committees can report suspicious activity and rebuild public trust.
Conclusion: Encounters may calm public anger for a day, but they leave crimes unsolved and courts bypassed. Assam needs quick investigation and trial, under independent oversight, so that justice is both swift and lawful.
Prepare with SuchitraACS
APSC CCE Foundation Programme₹24,999
APSC Mains Mentorship Programme (MMP)₹9,999
APSC Prelims Crash Course 2027 (GS + CSAT)₹5,999 


